Antimicrobial Soaps vs. Other Soaps: What’s the Real Difference?

September 18, 2025

Other

Antimicrobial Soaps vs. Other Soaps: What’s the Real Difference?

When you pump a squirt of soap from the dispenser, you probably don’t give much thought to what kind of soap it is. Most of us simply want to wash our hands, get rid of soils, and feel fresh. But not all soaps are created equal. In fact, if you’ve ever noticed the label “antimicrobial” or “antibacterial” on a bottle, you’ve probably wondered: how is this different from regular soap?

The truth is, there’s a lot of nuance here. Antimicrobial soaps are designed to target and reduce microorganisms more aggressively than plain soaps, but that doesn’t always mean they’re better for every situation.

In this article, we’ll break down the key differences between antimicrobial soaps and other major types of soaps, including plain soap, antibacterial soap, and specialty soaps like moisturizing or deodorant soaps.

We’ll also look at how each type of soap works, where they’re best used, and what science says about their effectiveness. By the end, you’ll have a clear understanding of when an antimicrobial soap makes sense and when a simpler option may be the smarter choice.

Let’s get started!

The Big Picture: Soap’s Role in Hygiene

Before we compare the different types of soap, it’s worth revisiting what soap does in the first place. At its core, soap is a surfactant. That means it lowers the surface tension between oil, dirt, and water, allowing you to wash away debris from your skin.

When you scrub with soap and rinse with water, you’re physically removing germs and grime from your hands. Regular soap doesn’t kill germs outright; it just lifts them off your skin so they can be rinsed down the drain.

Antimicrobial soaps, on the other hand, are formulated with added ingredients that are meant to actively kill or inhibit the growth of microorganisms.

That difference, removal versus destruction, is why you need to compare antimicrobial soaps versus other types of soaps.

Comparison Table: Antimicrobial vs. Other Soaps

Here’s a side-by-side look at how antimicrobial soaps stack up against other common soap types:

Category	Antimicrobial Soap	Plain Soap	Antibacterial Soap	Moisturizing / Deodorant Soap
Primary Function	Kills or inhibits bacteria, fungi, and some viruses	Removes dirt, oils, and microbes mechanically	Kills or inhibits bacteria only	Cleans while adding fragrance, moisture, or skin conditioners
Active Ingredients	Triclosan (formerly), chloroxylenol, benzalkonium chloride, alcohol, or plant-based antimicrobials	Traditional fats/oils + lye (sodium hydroxide)	Triclosan, triclocarban, benzalkonium chloride	Moisturizers (glycerin, shea butter), deodorizing agents, fragrances
Effectiveness	High against a broad range of microbes	Effective at cleaning, reduces germs via rinsing	Effective against bacteria but not viruses	Primarily cosmetic, effectiveness depends on formulation
Best Use Cases	Healthcare settings, foodservice, high-risk areas	Everyday handwashing for general public	Households with vulnerable individuals; food prep	Daily skincare, odor control, hydration
Regulation	Closely monitored by FDA/CDC (in U.S.)	General cosmetic regulations	Regulated; some ingredients phased out	Regulated as cosmetics
Potential Drawbacks	Can cause skin dryness; may promote resistance if overused	None significant; gentle on skin	Risk of bacterial resistance; limited spectrum	May irritate sensitive skin; less germ-focused

Antimicrobial Soaps vs. Other Soaps

Now, let’s dig deeper into each of these categories so you can see how these soaps compare in practice:

1. Primary Function: What Each Soap is Designed to Do
2. Active Ingredients: What’s Inside the Bottle
3. Effectiveness: Do They Really Work?
4. Best Use Cases: Where to Use Each
5. Regulation: How Much Oversight?
6. Potential Drawbacks: What to Watch Out For

1. Primary Function: What Each Soap is Designed to Do

The first key difference lies in what the soap is designed to achieve.

Antimicrobial soap is formulated to kill or inhibit not just bacteria, but also fungi and some viruses. This makes it a broader-spectrum option than antibacterial soaps, which target only bacteria.

Plain soap doesn’t kill germs directly. Instead, it’s about removal. By breaking up oils and suspending particles, plain soap lets you rinse bacteria, viruses, and dirt off your skin.
Antibacterial soap targets bacteria specifically, using chemicals that disrupt their cell walls or interfere with their function. However, it doesn’t necessarily affect viruses.
Moisturizing or deodorant soaps put skin feel and scent first. They clean, of course, but they’re designed for cosmetic benefits like fragrance and hydration more than microbial control.

In short: antimicrobial soaps are focused on germ-killing, while plain soaps and specialty soaps prioritize cleanliness, comfort, or cosmetic benefits.

Active Ingredients: What’s Inside the Bottle

One of the biggest distinctions between these soaps is what goes into them.

Antimicrobial soaps may contain ingredients such as chloroxylenol, benzalkonium chloride, or alcohol. In some cases, natural plant extracts with antimicrobial properties are used. These ingredients directly kill or slow the growth of microbes. Triclosan, once a common ingredient, has been phased out in the U.S. due to safety concerns.

Plain soaps are made through the process of saponification—combining fats or oils with lye. The result is a cleansing bar or liquid without special germ-killing additives.
Antibacterial soaps often used triclosan or triclocarban, though these too have been restricted in many markets. Alternatives like benzalkonium chloride remain.
Moisturizing and deodorant soaps include ingredients such as glycerin, aloe vera, shea butter, or fragrances. These don’t kill microbes but instead improve skin hydration or add scent.

Pro Tip: If you’re buying soap for germ control, you’ll want a soap with antimicrobial agents in its formulation. If you just want clean, comfortable skin, plain or moisturizing soap might be enough.

Effectiveness: Do They Really Work?

Let’s take a look at how effective each type of soap is:

Antimicrobial soap has been shown to reduce the presence of many microbes, including some viruses and fungi, more effectively than plain soap in laboratory conditions. In high-risk environments, this can make a measurable difference.
Plain soap is surprisingly effective on its own. By removing germs physically, it significantly reduces infection risk. In fact, many public health organizations, including the CDC, emphasize that plain soap is sufficient for everyday use.
Antibacterial soap is good at reducing bacteria, but since viruses are unaffected, its benefits are limited compared to antimicrobial soap.
Moisturizing or deodorant soaps can clean just as well as plain soap, but unless they include antimicrobial additives, they don’t provide additional germ protection.

So, does antimicrobial soap always outperform plain soap? Not necessarily. In everyday household use, studies suggest the difference in infection prevention is minimal. The real advantage appears in clinical or foodservice environments where exposure risks are higher.

4. Best Use Cases: Where to Use Each

Not every situation calls for antimicrobial soap.

Antimicrobial soap is most useful in healthcare facilities, foodservice kitchens, or other high-risk settings where exposure to pathogens is common.

Plain soap is perfectly suitable for general handwashing at home, school, or the office. It’s the go-to choice for the average person.
Antibacterial soap can be useful in households with immunocompromised individuals or when preparing food, but since plain soap is so effective, the benefit is often marginal.
Moisturizing or deodorant soaps are great for daily showers or if you struggle with dry skin. They’re more about comfort and personal care than infection control.

Choosing the right soap often comes down to matching the product to your environment and needs.

5. Regulation: How Much Oversight?

In the United States, the FDA’s soap regulation typically depends on how the product is marketed.

Antimicrobial soaps are considered over-the-counter drugs if they make claims about killing germs. That means the FDA regulates them closely, requiring proof of safety and effectiveness.
Plain soaps are generally regulated as cosmetics by the FDA, since they’re intended for cleansing but not disease prevention.
Antibacterial soaps fall under the same rules as antimicrobial soaps, and many active ingredients have been restricted or banned.
Moisturizing and deodorant soaps are usually regulated as cosmetics unless they make specific germ-related claims.

This regulatory oversight helps ensure consumers are protected, and it also explains why certain ingredients, like triclosan, have disappeared from store shelves in recent years.

Potential Drawbacks: What to Watch Out For

Like many products, different kinds of soaps can come with trade-offs.

Antimicrobial soaps may cause skin dryness or irritation with frequent use, especially if they contain harsh chemicals. There’s also concern about contributing to antimicrobial resistance when overused.
Plain soap is gentle and effective, with no major downsides other than lacking any “extra” germ-killing power.
Antibacterial soaps face criticism for encouraging bacterial resistance and for giving consumers a false sense of added protection.
Moisturizing or deodorant soaps can irritate sensitive skin due to fragrances or additives, and they may not address germ reduction as effectively.

Pro Tip: If you’re prone to skin issues, fragrance-free plain soap is often the safest bet.

The Bigger Debate: Do We Really Need Antimicrobial Soap?

One of the ongoing debates in public health is whether antimicrobial soaps are truly necessary outside of professional settings.

The CDC maintains that regular soap and water are sufficient for most people in everyday life. The mechanical action of washing for at least 20 seconds does the heavy lifting, and antimicrobial ingredients don’t add much in terms of preventing illness at home.

On the other hand, in hospitals, nursing homes, and foodservice kitchens, where contamination risks are higher, antimicrobial soaps can provide an extra layer of protection. For example, reducing fungal transmission in healthcare or limiting cross-contamination in food prep.

In other words, antimicrobial soaps are a valuable tool—but not always the right one for your bathroom sink.

Final Thoughts

At the end of the day, the best soap for you depends on your needs.

If you’re working in a healthcare or foodservice environment, antimicrobial soaps may be worth it.
If you’re at home or in the office, plain soap is usually all you need.
If comfort and skin health are your top priorities, moisturizing or specialty soaps might be the way to go.

What matters most isn’t the label on the bottle; it’s your handwashing habits. Washing thoroughly, scrubbing for at least 20 seconds, and rinsing well are what keep you healthy, no matter what kind of soap you use.

So when it comes time to choose the right soap for your facility, you’ll know exactly what those labels mean and how to pick the soap that actually fits your needs.

Need help installing a handwashing program in your facility? Reach out to the experts at Imperial Dade! Our staff can provide the product samples and demos you need to make the most educated decision for your staff and patrons.